Why South Africans Prefer Buying Cars from the USA

I remember my cousin, Thabo, sitting at a coffee shop in Johannesburg scrolling through listings on his phone. He had been looking for a reliable SUV for months. Local dealerships offered a range of options, but prices seemed inflated, mileage was high, and the stories about “reconditioned” cars made him nervous. After a bit of research, he started browsing U.S. car auctions. Within a week, he had found a pristine 2016 Toyota Fortuner at a price that seemed almost too good to be true. A few months later, the SUV rolled into Durban port, and he couldn’t stop grinning.

Thabo’s story isn’t unique. Increasingly, South Africans are turning their gaze across the Atlantic, seeking vehicles in the United States. But why? What makes U.S. cars so appealing, and what drives this trend despite the logistical hurdles of international shipping? Let’s explore the reasons behind this growing preference.

Better Prices, Often With Better Quality

One of the first things that jumps out is price. U.S. used cars are often more affordable than comparable models in South Africa. Take a mid-range SUV like the Toyota RAV4 or Ford Escape. In the U.S., a 2017 model in good condition might cost around $12,000. In South Africa, similar vehicles are listed for R350,000 to R450,000—sometimes even higher depending on location and condition.

It’s not just about the sticker price. Many U.S. cars have lower mileage, detailed service histories, and better maintenance records. Thabo’s Fortuner, for instance, had been driven lightly, serviced at a dealership, and even had a clean Carfax report. Compare that to some local options where odometer tampering and spotty service histories are all too common, and it’s easy to see why South Africans might consider the U.S. a better option.

Wide Selection, Especially for Specific Preferences

Another reason is variety. South African dealerships can be limited in inventory, especially when it comes to certain models or trims. If you’re looking for a Jeep Wrangler with a specific off-road package, or a limited-edition pickup, your options locally might be near nonexistent. In contrast, U.S. markets offer a staggering array of makes, models, trims, and years.

I’ve seen friends spend weeks searching dealerships in Cape Town and Pretoria only to end up settling for a version that “sort of” matched what they wanted. Browsing U.S. sites, however, often feels like walking through an endless showroom where almost anything is possible—automatic or manual, diesel or petrol, leather interiors, sunroofs, and more. The ability to pick exactly what you want is a huge draw.

Perceived Reliability and Safety

There’s also a perception factor. Many South Africans believe that U.S. cars are safer and more reliable. This perception is partly rooted in experience—cars in the U.S. often undergo rigorous inspections, have access to parts, and are maintained according to strict manufacturer guidelines.

Take my own experience. My uncle imported a Honda CR-V from the U.S. in 2018. He joked that the car “felt like it rolled off a showroom floor every time he drove it.” Compare that to some locally sourced cars, where interiors show early wear and tear despite low mileage. While not every U.S. car is flawless, the perception of quality tends to influence buyer decisions.

Lower Risk of Fraud or Hidden Issues

South Africa’s used car market, while improving, still has occasional cases of fraud. Cars may have rolled back odometers, been in accidents with little disclosure, or have hidden mechanical issues. The U.S. market offers transparency tools like Carfax or AutoCheck, which allow buyers to track a vehicle’s history in detail.

Thabo, for example, relied on Carfax before committing to his Fortuner. The report confirmed the car had never been in a major accident, had consistent service records, and no hidden liens. That peace of mind—knowing the vehicle’s history is verifiable—makes the import process more appealing despite shipping costs.

Cost-Effectiveness After Shipping

At first glance, shipping a car from the U.S. seems expensive. Shipping, insurance, customs duties, and VAT can quickly add R150,000–R250,000 to the total cost. Yet, for many buyers, the final price still undercuts comparable vehicles bought locally.

I’ve seen it play out with friends importing SUVs and pickups. They might pay $15,000 for a vehicle and another $12,000 for shipping and duties. The total investment, around R500,000, often lands below the local market for equivalent cars. Add the lower mileage and verified condition, and the deal can feel like a bargain rather than an indulgence.

Access to Vehicles Not Widely Available Locally

Some models or engine types simply aren’t sold in South Africa. U.S. buyers might be able to choose features like hybrid engines, higher towing capacity, or specific trims unavailable in local showrooms. This is particularly true for American brands like Ford, Chevrolet, or Jeep.

A friend once wanted a Chevrolet Silverado with a diesel engine for work purposes. Locally, no dealer stocked that configuration. Importing from the U.S. was the only option—and he was willing to pay the extra shipping because the vehicle perfectly matched his needs.

The Role of Freight Forwarders and Agents

Of course, navigating the import process can be daunting. That’s where freight forwarders, clearing agents, and brokers come in. They simplify paperwork, coordinate shipping, and handle customs clearance. Without them, buyers might struggle with import permits, SARS regulations, or port logistics.

When Thabo imported his Fortuner, he relied on a freight forwarder based in Miami who coordinated shipping to Durban. The forwarder handled U.S. export paperwork, insurance, container loading, and even liaised with South African customs. The result? His car arrived in perfect condition, and the entire process, while stressful at times, was far smoother than it could have been alone.

A Sense of Status and Pride

For some buyers, it’s not just about practicality—it’s about prestige. Owning a car directly imported from the U.S., especially models not widely available locally, carries a certain cachet. It signals attention to detail, willingness to invest in quality, and sometimes simply the joy of owning exactly what you want without compromise.

I’ve watched colleagues in Johannesburg beam with pride as they drove past dealerships in SUVs or pickups that were otherwise hard to find locally. The status aspect, while subtle, is part of the appeal.

Challenges and Considerations

It’s not all sunshine. Importing a car from the U.S. comes with logistical challenges:

Currency fluctuations: Paying in dollars can make the total cost unpredictable.

Shipping delays: Weather, port congestion, or documentation errors can slow delivery.

Customs complexity: Duties, VAT, and ITAC permits must be navigated correctly.

Insurance coverage: Adequate shipping insurance is necessary to protect against damage or loss.

Some buyers underestimate these hurdles and discover, often the hard way, that importing isn’t just clicking “buy now” on a website. Yet, those who prepare and work with experienced agents tend to have positive outcomes.

Why the Trend Continues

Despite these challenges, the trend shows no sign of slowing. The combination of lower prices, verified vehicle histories, variety, and the ability to access models unavailable locally keeps the U.S. market attractive to South Africans. Add in growing familiarity with freight forwarders, clearing agents, and online car auctions, and the process feels increasingly manageable.

I’ve also noticed a generational element. Younger buyers, comfortable with digital platforms and international payments, are more willing to navigate the process than older generations, who might prefer local dealerships for convenience and perceived safety.

Personal Reflection

Having observed multiple friends and relatives import cars, I can say that the appeal of U.S. vehicles is both practical and aspirational. It’s not just about saving money or avoiding mileage fraud—it’s about choice, control, and confidence in what you’re buying. The experience, while occasionally stressful, is rewarding when the vehicle finally arrives, inspected, and ready to drive.

Conclusion

South Africans prefer buying cars from the USA for several reasons: affordability, verified quality, variety, access to unique models, and the reassurance of documented vehicle history. While shipping and customs duties add cost and complexity, the overall benefits often outweigh the drawbacks. For many, the decision comes down to one simple truth: importing a car allows you to get exactly what you want, how you want it, and with a level of assurance that local markets sometimes struggle to provide.

Whether it’s the thrill of finding the perfect SUV at a bargain price, the reassurance of a detailed service history, or simply the satisfaction of owning a vehicle not commonly seen on local roads, the U.S. remains a top destination for South African car buyers—and likely will for years to come.

Published on: Sep 07, 2025

Related Post